Short answer: For a perfume similar to Jo Malone Red Roses but cheaper, Shay & Blue’s Wild Roses Perfume is the standout choice: dewy rose, juicy green brightness and a warm, sensual finish at £60 for 100ml. Against Red Roses Cologne’s listed £125 for 100ml, it offers a lower-priced route to fresh rose character, with a distinctive personality rather than an imitation. This Nose Dive roundup separates the rose-led choices from fragrances that explore the same fresh, botanical mood.
Comparison at a glance

A rose-led alternative with its own note profile, rather than an identical copy.
£60.00£0.60 per ml
About 52% less per ml than Jo Malone London Red Roses Cologne.
Shop Wild Roses| Fragrance | Key notes | Best for | Price | Price per ml |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Wild RosesShay & Blue · 100ml
|
Key notes · Rose dew, king william pear and davana flower, patchouli, orange blossom and pink amber | Rose-led fragrance | £60.00 | £0.60 |
MatchaShay & Blue · 100ml
|
Key notes · Shiso, matcha, violet leaf, patchouli, bergamot and soft apple wood | Tea-led fragrance | £60.00 | £0.60 |
Orange BlossomShay & Blue · 100ml
|
Key notes · Neroli and amalfi mandarin, orange blossom and white orchid, cashmeran and sandalwood | Citrus-led fragrance | £60.00 | £0.60 |
Red Roses CologneJo Malone London · 100ml
|
Top · Lemon and mintHeart · Bulgarian rose and violet leafBase · Beeswax | Rose-led fragrance | £125.00↗ | £1.25 |
Rose Eau de ParfumPaul Smith
|
Top · Rose, green tea and violetHeart · Turkish rose and magnoliaBase · Musk and cedar | Rose-led fragrance | Not listed | Not listed |
Competitor prices: official listings checked 2026-11-13. Prices refer to the sizes shown. Not listed means no verified price is available in the saved sources.
The verdict: Wild Roses is the pick for rose-led fragrance, with its own composition rather than a promise to duplicate Jo Malone London Red Roses Cologne.
Shop all alternatives →Wild Roses

Best for the shopper who wants to keep rose at the centre while spending less. Wild Roses Perfume opens with Rose Dew: crystal-clear, transparent and full of that early-morning garden feeling. King William Pear and Davana Flower bring a juicy, green heart, giving the bloom movement rather than turning it into a formal bouquet. At £60 for 100ml, this is the most direct Shay & Blue recommendation for the query: a fresh rose fragrance with a clearly lower bottle price and a character worth choosing in its own right.
The distinction sits in the journey. Wild Roses Perfume starts off fresh but dries down to Patchouli, Orange Blossom and Pink Amber, trading the opening’s sheer light for warmth and sensuality. The effect is a rose with a free-spirited edge: romantic, yet more unbuttoned than ceremonial. It suits an aesthetic of open windows, loose linen and flowers still carrying the freshness of the garden. For a closer look at that balance, the Wild Roses and Red Roses comparison explores the pairing. The appeal here is not a promise of identical scent; it is a confident new interpretation of the fresh-rose idea.
Jo Malone London Red Roses Cologne
The benchmark, rather than a cheaper alternative. Red Roses Cologne provides the reference point for this search, so its structure matters: Lemon and Mint at the top, Bulgarian Rose and Violet Leaf in the middle, and Beeswax at the base, according to its listed fragrance notes. That combination gives the comparison three useful directions: the bright opening, the rose-and-leaf heart, and the contrasting base. A shopper drawn mainly to the rose has a different brief from someone whose favourite part is the leafy freshness around it.
The supplied official listing places the 100ml bottle at £125, checked on 13 November 2026. That makes equal-size comparison straightforward against the £60 Shay & Blue bottles in this edit. Red Roses belongs here as the scent and price benchmark, not as a recommendation for saving money. The most useful question is which part of its composition deserves to survive the switch. Wild Roses Perfume keeps the rose-led focus; the greener and white-floral options below offer a deliberate change of direction. This distinction keeps a lower-price search meaningful rather than treating every floral fragrance as interchangeable.
Paul Smith Rose Eau de Parfum
A rose-led scent comparison for the shortlist. Paul Smith Rose Eau de Parfum combines Rose, Green Tea and Violet at the top with Turkish Rose and Magnolia in the heart, finishing on Musk and Cedar. Those rose, tea and floral notes make it a relevant companion to a Red Roses search. Rose is present in both its opening and heart, while Green Tea gives the composition a botanical point of interest. On notes alone, this is a more direct rose comparison than a fragrance built entirely around another flower.
Its role in this roundup is scent comparison rather than a ranked price recommendation. The useful contrast is between two different settings for rose: tea, violet and magnolia here; dewy rose, pear and davana in Wild Roses Perfume. The Paul Smith composition is worth placing on the smelling shortlist when the flower itself is non-negotiable. For a purchase decision led by a stated £60 budget, Wild Roses Perfume remains the clear recommendation in this edit. Keeping those two decisions separate—preferred scent direction and actual bottle spend—makes the shortlist more practical, especially for a shopper who wants a beautiful rose rather than simply another bottle bearing the word.
Matcha
Best for the shopper whose real priority is greenery rather than petals. At £60 for 100ml, Matcha Perfume takes the botanical route with cool Shiso and Matcha, a textured core of Violet Leaf and Patchouli, and brightness from Bergamot and soft Apple Wood. It is a purposeful departure from rose, not a rose substitute in disguise. The connection to this search is the pleasure of something fresh, leafy and polished: a fragrance that feels considered without needing a lavish bouquet at its centre.
Matcha Perfume brings a different scene into focus: a slow terrace morning, a crisp shirt, a quiet pause before the city gathers speed. Its clean character is balanced by earthy texture and soft woods, with a lingering trail that stays true to its green identity. For someone who likes the idea of a garden more than the flower arrangement, this is a compelling £60 direction. The guide to comparing floral character offers another way to think about what matters in a fragrance switch. The buying distinction is simple: Wild Roses Perfume preserves a rose-led mood; Matcha Perfume makes botanical freshness the main event.

Orange Blossom

Best for a romantic floral mood with a different flower in the spotlight. Orange Blossom Perfume costs £60 for 100ml and opens with Neroli and Amalfi Mandarin before unfolding into Orange Blossom and White Orchid. It answers the softer version of this shopper brief: something freshly floral, luminous and elegant, without requiring rose itself. Where Wild Roses Perfume offers transparent dew and juicy green energy, this fragrance moves towards creamy white petals. The result is an alternative by atmosphere, not a claim of matching notes.
Cashmeran and Sandalwood give the finish its warm, velvety character. That makes Orange Blossom Perfume particularly appealing to a shopper who enjoys a bright beginning but wants the composition to settle into softness. The mood is clean fabric, pale flowers and a little warmth at the end of the afternoon: delicate and romantic, with an inviting texture. It is a strong choice when the attraction to Red Roses is the broader idea of an elegant fresh floral. When recognisable rose is the essential requirement, Wild Roses Perfume takes priority; when creamy petals and a softly woody finish sound more enticing, Orange Blossom Perfume earns its place.
How to choose
The first decision is whether the brief is about a flower or a feeling. For a rose-centred replacement, Wild Roses Perfume leads this edit, with Paul Smith Rose Eau de Parfum serving as another rose-led scent comparison. For the feeling of botanical freshness, Matcha Perfume opens a greener door. For luminous floral romance, Orange Blossom Perfume offers creamy petals and softness. These are distinct routes, and choosing between them is more useful than chasing a vague promise of smelling expensive.
The next step is an equal-size price comparison. The three Shay & Blue fragrances featured here are each £60 for 100ml, against the supplied £125 listing for Red Roses Cologne in the same volume. That answers the cheaper part of the query without confusing a smaller bottle with better value. The closer look at the two rose compositions helps refine the scent decision once the budget is settled. Price establishes the shortlist; the preferred floral or green character determines the winner.
Finally, the opening and finish deserve separate attention during sampling. Wild Roses Perfume moves from transparent rose into warm Pink Amber and Patchouli; Matcha Perfume favours crisp greenery and soft wood; Orange Blossom Perfume moves from radiant citrus into a velvety base. A useful comparison follows each fragrance beyond the first impression rather than selecting only the brightest opening. For this particular search, the final recommendation remains Wild Roses Perfume: rose-led, sensorially distinctive and clearly priced below the benchmark.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best cheaper alternative to Jo Malone Red Roses in this roundup?
Wild Roses Perfume is the strongest match to the brief. Its Rose Dew opening keeps the focus on fresh rose, while King William Pear and Davana Flower add juicy green brightness. At £60 for 100ml, it offers a lower-priced choice with a warm, distinctive finish.
Is Wild Roses Perfume an exact dupe of Red Roses?
It is a fresh-rose alternative, not an identical composition. Wild Roses Perfume follows its dewy opening with pear and davana, then Patchouli, Orange Blossom and Pink Amber. The reason to choose it is the combination of recognisable rose character, its own expressive development and the lower bottle price.
Which option suits someone who wants less emphasis on flowers?
Matcha Perfume is the green-led choice. Shiso, Matcha, Violet Leaf and Patchouli create a crisp, textured botanical character, with Bergamot and soft Apple Wood bringing brightness and polish. It shifts the search away from rose towards leafy freshness rather than replacing one floral bouquet with another.
Which option starts fresh and finishes warm?
Wild Roses Perfume and Orange Blossom Perfume both fit that preference in different ways. Wild Roses Perfume travels from transparent Rose Dew towards Pink Amber and Patchouli. Orange Blossom Perfume begins with Neroli and Amalfi Mandarin, then settles into the smooth warmth of Cashmeran and Sandalwood.
Welcome to...
Austria
Belgium








Share:
Lilacs & Gooseberries vs. Jo Malone English Pear & Freesia: Choosing Your Signature Floral
Which Zodiac Sign Matches Your Signature Shay & Blue Perfume?